Beehiiv vs Substack vs Kit (2026): Which Should You Use?

If you run any kind of email list, last week was a good week to pay attention. On October 1, beehiiv rewrote its plans: the Scale tier became Lite, Max became Pro, and prices went up right where grown-up newsletters live. Tyler Denk, the company’s cofounder and CEO, says it’s only the second pricing change in beehiiv’s near five-year history, and existing customers keep their current rate until their first renewal on or after November 1.

Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through one of them, this site may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

That announcement landed on a question I already get constantly, in one form or another. Not “should I start a newsletter.” Which platform should it live on. Beehiiv, Substack, and Kit come up in almost every one of those conversations, so I spent a few evenings with the new pricing pages, the announcement post, and the reaction threads, and put the three of them side by side.

Key Takeaways

  • Substack is still the cheapest way to start: no monthly fee at any list size. The catch is 10% of your paid subscription revenue forever, plus card processing.
  • beehiiv’s new Lite plan runs $139 a month at 10,000 subscribers, up from $109. It makes sense once the newsletter earns money; before that, the free plan (2,500 subscribers) does the job.
  • Kit’s free plan covers up to 10,000 subscribers, but visual automations and sequences sit behind paid plans that start around $33 a month.
  • Selling digital products costs the least on beehiiv (0% platform fee). Kit Commerce charges 3.5% + $0.30 per sale, card processing included. Substack doesn’t really sell products at all.

How I put this together

One honesty note before the numbers. My own lists run on Buttondown, a smaller player in this exact market, so I’ve watched this trio the way people watch sports they don’t play. Everything below comes from each vendor’s own pricing pages (re-checked the first week of October 2026), beehiiv’s October announcement, and outside reporting including The Verge. Where I couldn’t confirm a number to the dollar, I’ll give you the range instead of a fake decimal point. I also have not personally migrated a large list between all three, so when we get to switching costs I’ll keep it brief and qualitative.

Substack: free until the money shows up

Substack’s model is easy to explain and easier to underestimate. The platform costs nothing. Hosting, a clean archive site, an app, and a recommendations network, all free. The bill only appears when your paid subscriptions do: 10% of everything, permanently, on top of Stripe’s standard processing (about 2.9% plus 30 cents per charge).

On a $5 monthly subscription, Substack’s fee plus processing already eats roughly 19 cents of every dollar before anything else gets a look in. If a reader subscribes inside the iOS app during the first year, Apple’s cut shows up on top of that. Run it forward on a real list and it gets uncomfortable: a newsletter doing $5,000 a month in paid revenue sends about $500 a month, or $6,000 a year, to Substack alone.

That’s not a ripoff, it’s a funding model. You pay nothing while the list earns nothing, and the platform gets paid as you grow. For writers who want to think about nothing but the writing, that trade is still fair. But it’s the single most expensive line item in a newsletter business once that business actually works, and it never shrinks.

beehiiv: what the new pricing actually says

The October 1 reshuffle gave every plan a new name and some new limits. Here’s the short version, using beehiiv’s own numbers:

  • Free stays free and still covers up to 2,500 subscribers, now with more of the core products included from day one.
  • Lite (the old Scale) costs $139 a month at 10,000 subscribers, up from $109.
  • Pro (the old Max) costs $239 a month at 10,000 subscribers, up from $219, and now runs self-serve all the way to 250,000 subscribers without a sales call.
  • Paying annually lands you up to two months free.

Two things survived the reshuffle unchanged, and they’re the two that matter for the comparison. beehiiv still takes 0% of your paid subscription revenue, and it still takes 0% on digital products sold through the platform. The revenue-share line that dominates Substack conversations simply doesn’t exist here.

The other structural difference is the ad network. beehiiv’s built-in ad marketplace connects your newsletter to sponsors and, per the company, now pays out more than $1 million a month to creators. Free newsletters can earn this way, which matters given the pricing math below.

The reaction to the new prices has been split in a genuinely useful way. Matt Brown, who writes the Extra Points newsletter, called beehiiv a steal compared with Substack, while noting that’s not true for publishers who never charge a subscription fee. Freelance journalist Tim Stevens described the change, from his seat, as a 25% hike. Meanwhile, other paid writers keep moving onto the platform. Matt Lombardo recently relocated his NFL newsletter Between the Hashmarks from Substack to beehiiv, which is the pattern in miniature: paid newsletters run the math and land on flat pricing, free newsletters stare at a growing monthly fee and wonder what it buys them.

That tension is real, and both sides are right. A free newsletter with 10,000 subscribers can run on Substack forever at $0 fixed cost. On beehiiv’s Lite plan it pays $139 a month. If the ad network and Boosts don’t roughly cover that gap, the free newsletter overpaid. But a paid newsletter charging $80 a year from 2,000 readers earns $160,000 in gross revenue each year. Substack’s 10% takes $16,000. beehiiv Lite takes $1,668. That’s not close.

Kit: the free-list specialist with a paid brain

Kit, the platform formerly known as ConvertKit, plays a third hand entirely. Its free Newsletter plan handles up to 10,000 subscribers with unlimited landing pages, forms, and broadcasts, and even its commerce system works on the free tier. Of the three, Kit offers the most generous free list. The trap is what the free tier leaves out: visual automations, the automation library, and email sequences are all paid-plan features. A welcome sequence, lead magnet delivery, a nurture series, that’s the core reason people pick Kit, and none of it wakes up until you’re paying.

On paid tiers, Kit’s pricing page currently lists Creator at $33 a month and Pro at $66. One wrinkle worth flagging: independent trackers recorded Creator at $39 and Pro at $79 as recently as September, and Kit’s prices scale with your list size, so treat those figures as entry numbers and use their pricing slider for your actual count before you budget anything. Paid plans also bundle a referral system built on SparkLoop, which Kit values at $99 a month if bought separately.

When you sell through Kit Commerce, the platform charges 3.5% plus $0.30 per transaction, on every plan including free. Kit’s help center describes that rate as including card processing, so it stands in for Stripe rather than stacking on top of it. Not free like beehiiv, but cheaper than people assume and honest in a way Substack’s headline 10% is not.

Beehiiv vs Substack vs Kit, side by side

Substack beehiiv Kit
Free plan Yes, unlimited subscribers Up to 2,500 subscribers Up to 10,000 subscribers
How it charges 10% of paid subscription revenue + Stripe Flat monthly plans Flat monthly plans, commerce fee on sales
Fixed cost at 10,000 subs $0 $139/mo (Lite, new pricing) Creator plan, from $33/mo, scales with list
Paid newsletter take 10% forever 0% (Stripe processing only) 0% on subscriptions
Digital products Not supported 0% platform fee 3.5% + $0.30, processing included
Growth tools Recommendations network Recommendations, Boosts, ad network, SEO site builder Recommendations, SparkLoop referrals (paid tiers)
Automations & sequences Minimal Welcome series, re-engagement flows Visual automations, paid tiers only
Best fit Writers who want zero overhead Newsletters run as a business Creators selling courses and products

Where each one still wins

Substack’s edge is discovery and zero risk. Its recommendations network is the only genuinely free growth engine of the three: readers of similar publications find you while you sleep, and plenty of writers have built to five figures without spending a dollar. There’s also something to be said for a platform where the design decisions have already been made for you. You never fiddle with a template. The trade is the fee, weak automation, and little control over how your archive looks.

beehiiv’s edge is monetization under one roof. Paid subscriptions at 0%, digital products at 0%, an ad network that brings sponsors to you, Boosts if you want to pay for (or sell) growth, plus automations and a proper site builder. The new pricing leans into what the numbers above show: you’re paying beehiiv when you could be paying nothing, so you’d better be using the money-making parts. If your newsletter earns serious revenue, it’s the cheapest of the three by an order of magnitude. If it doesn’t yet, the free tier buys you time to get there.

Kit’s edge is the wider creator business. Ten thousand free subscribers is an absurdly good free tier, and once you’re paying, the automation and commerce tools go deeper than either competitor’s. People who sell courses, templates, or coaching, and plan to keep doing it for years, tend to settle here. The cost of that depth is friction: you’ll spend more time configuring Kit than you would either rival, and the free tier without automations is more limited than it first looks.

How to choose, in two minutes

  • You write essays, want discovery, and don’t want to think about software. Substack is still the answer.
  • Your newsletter is (or will be) the business itself: sponsors, paid tiers, products. beehiiv, start on free and upgrade when the math flips.
  • You’re building a whole creator business around the list, with products and sequenced funnels. Kit has the deepest toolkit, and the free tier lasts longest.

Whichever way you lean, the switch costs of staying wrong get worse every month your list grows. Imports between these platforms are normal operations at this point, and lists move with you, but paid-subscriber relationships and years of automation logic don’t relocate painlessly. The cheapest time to make this decision is at zero subscribers. The second cheapest is now.

Sources and fine print

beehiiv’s plan names and prices come from the company’s own October 1, 2026 announcement, with third-party confirmations in The Verge and trade press. beehiiv’s $1 million ad payout and 99.3% deliverability figures are company claims. Kit’s pricing comes from its own site and help center, cross-checked against independent trackers in August and September 2026. Substack’s fee structure is its published policy, with the effective take rates on small subscriptions documented by fee-tracking sites. Creator quotes come from reporting on the announcement. Every figure here was verified the first week of October 2026, and each of these platforms has been known to change a number or two, so click through to the pricing pages before you budget.

Curious how this site runs? The About page covers the stack, the standards, and the tools I consider worth paying for.

Scroll to Top